The Peyton Randolph House is the kind of place that reveals its real nature slowly. The corner lot on Nicholson Street looks, at first pass, like every other preserved colonial address in Williamsburg — handsome, well-maintained, historically appropriate. Then you learn that approximately 30 people died inside it across three centuries, and that the house has stood unoccupied by the living for years now, and something shifts in how the building looks when you glance back at it.
What sets this house apart from the Colonial Williamsburg showpieces is the density of loss it contains. A Founding Father who helped articulate American freedom while keeping 27 enslaved people on the property. A mother who outlived multiple children in the same rooms. A French general who survived the Revolution and couldn’t sleep one night in this house and felt compelled to write about it afterward. Two wars’ worth of wounded soldiers bleeding into the floorboards. These aren’t separate ghost stories layered on top of a building — they’re the building’s actual history, and they happen to have left a residue that visitors keep encountering.
Mary Monro Peachy is the most frequently reported presence, seen moving through the upstairs hallways of a house she never voluntarily left. Lafayette’s account from 1824 remains the earliest documented report and the one that’s hardest to dismiss — the man had been to actual battlefields, and he still wrote about his shoulder being grabbed. Adventure travelers who make it to Williamsburg typically head straight for the staged historical attractions. The smarter move is the quiet house on the corner, the one that’s empty, the one where something has apparently decided to wait.
Story Source: williamsburgghosttour.com
Address: 100 W Nicholson Street, Williamsburg, Virginia 23185
Accessibility Rating: Guided Tours Only — Access permitted only as part of an organized tour. Independent exploration not allowed.
Google Map
What Others Have Experienced
A visitor on the Colonial Ghosts walking tour in October 2017 said she photographed what looked like a small boy’s face in the house’s center window pane, snapped from the side while the rest of the group focused on the front of the building.
— from TripAdvisor (Karyn F)
A tour-goer in September 2014 said the Peyton Randolph House was her favorite stop on the walking tour, calling the stories about the house creepy enough to give the whole group goosebumps.
— from TripAdvisor (Rachaelpatteson)
A William & Mary student journalist recounted a story passed down among Colonial Williamsburg staff about a security guard who locked himself in for a routine check and went silent for nearly half an hour. When colleagues forced open a basement door that should only lock from the outside, they found him gripping his radio, insisting something had physically held him in place. He quit two weeks later.
— from Flat Hat Magazine (JR Herman)
A paranormal researcher’s writeup describes a security guard who, while locking up for the night, reported hearing children’s laughter and the patter of small feet running across an empty floor.
— from M.A. Kleen (michaelkleen.com)
