On July 11, 2002, a quiet evening in Belmont County, Ohio, is shattered by a single, fatal gunshot. John Cornelius “J.C.” McGhee collapses at the threshold of his own home. Initially, his sudden death is cloaked in the benign guise of a heart attack, offering his family an illusion of peace. Little do they know, a more sinister truth lurks beneath the surface—a truth that will remain hidden for years.

Crime scene illustration

The reality of J.C.’s murder remains buried until his daughter, Madison McGhee, embarks on a quest for answers. Her journey is fraught with the chilling realization that her father was not a victim of fate but rather of a calculated homicide. As she delves deeper, the shadows of that July evening grow longer, casting doubt and suspicion across the community.

The revelation of the true cause of J.C.’s death sends ripples through Belmont County, challenging perceptions and demanding justice. The once-cold trail heats up, igniting a pursuit for accountability and closure. The McGhee case evolves from a family’s private sorrow into a public quest for truth, leaving an indelible mark on all who seek to unravel its mysteries.

Story Source: True crime podcast titled “A Case As Cold As Ice” (Ice Cold Case)